The #1 Mistake: Recording Only the Amazon Disbursement
Amazon pays you every two weeks — a net disbursement after deducting referral fees, fulfillment fees, storage fees, advertising costs, refunds, and reserves. Many FBA sellers simply record this bank deposit as "Amazon income" and move on. This is wrong for two reasons:
- You lose the breakdown of gross sales vs fee expense — you cannot see your true gross margin
- FBA fees are business expenses that should be categorized separately (selling fees, fulfillment fees, storage, PPC advertising) for accurate P&L reporting
The correct approach: record gross sales as revenue, record each fee type as a separate expense, and reconcile the net disbursement to your bank account. A2X automates this reconciliation — it pulls your Amazon settlement data directly into QuickBooks.
The FBA Seller P&L — What Each Line Actually Represents
| Line Item | What It Is | Where It Goes |
|---|---|---|
| Gross product sales | Total revenue from customer orders | Revenue |
| Refunds/returns | Revenue reversed when customers return items | Contra-revenue (deducted from gross sales) |
| COGS | Cost of inventory sold (purchase price + inbound shipping) | Cost of Goods Sold |
| Referral fees | Amazon's % commission (typically 8–15% of sale price) | Selling expense |
| FBA fulfillment fees | Per-unit pick, pack, ship fee | Fulfillment expense |
| FBA storage fees | Monthly fee per cubic foot stored | Storage expense |
| Sponsored Products (PPC) | Amazon advertising spend | Advertising expense |
| FBA reimbursements | Amazon repaying you for lost/damaged inventory | Other income (or COGS offset) |
| Subscription fee ($39.99/mo) | Amazon Professional selling plan | Platform fees expense |
COGS Tracking — The Inventory Problem
For an FBA seller, COGS calculation is:
Beginning Inventory (at cost) + Inventory Purchases + Inbound Shipping − Ending Inventory (at cost) = COGS
You need to know, at year-end, the cost value of every unit sitting in Amazon's warehouses. This requires either:
- Inventory Lab or Sellerboard: Tracks unit costs and auto-calculates COGS as items sell
- A2X with inventory module: Pulls settlement data and applies unit costs
- Manual spreadsheet: Works for small product counts, becomes unmanageable at scale
At Sharma Jyoti and Co we work with your inventory tracking tool to pull accurate COGS figures monthly. At year-end we perform an inventory reconciliation — Amazon inventory report vs your COGS ledger — to catch discrepancies before they become tax problems.
Sales Tax Nexus — What FBA Sellers Must Know After Wayfair
Marketplace Facilitator rules (the good news): In all 50 states with sales tax, Amazon collects and remits sales tax on FBA sales as the marketplace facilitator. You generally do not need to collect tax — Amazon does it for you. But you may still need to:
- Register for a sales tax permit in nexus states (required in some states even if Amazon collects)
- File periodic sales tax returns showing $0 owed (Amazon collected on your behalf)
- Track exempt sales (wholesale, resale) separately
Sales tax compliance for FBA sellers is a specialist area — we recommend TaxJar or Avalara for automated nexus monitoring and filing, coordinated with your bookkeeping records.
What Sharma Jyoti and Co Handles Monthly
- Amazon settlement reconciliation via A2X — gross sales, fees, refunds, all categorized
- Bank reconciliation — disbursements matched to QuickBooks
- COGS calculation using your inventory tool data
- Ending inventory valuation monthly (important for management P&L visibility)
- FBA reimbursement tracking — Amazon owes you money for lost/damaged inventory
- Monthly P&L — gross sales, gross margin (after COGS), operating expenses, net profit
- Year-end inventory count reconciliation and COGS finalization for your CPA
- 1099-K reconciliation — matching Amazon-reported gross sales to your records
Cost Comparison
| Provider | Monthly Cost | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| US e-commerce bookkeeper | $600–$2,000/mo | FBA specialist knowledge adds cost |
| Bean Ninjas / FBA specialist firms | $500–$1,500/mo | FBA-specific but expensive |
| Sharma Jyoti and Co | $250–$500/mo | A2X-connected QuickBooks, settlement reconciliation, COGS tracking, inventory valuation, year-end workpapers |