Head-to-Head Comparison — Bench vs Major Alternatives
| Provider | Starting Price | Software | Data Portable? | Year-End Workpapers | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bench | $299/mo | Proprietary | No — spreadsheet export only | Add-on (Premium tier) | Simple businesses wanting US-supervised platform |
| Pilot | $499/mo | QuickBooks | Yes | Included (Core+) | Startups, VC-backed companies |
| Bookkeeper360 | $399/mo | QuickBooks/Xero | Yes | Add-on | Small businesses wanting US-based team |
| US freelance bookkeeper | $400–$800/mo | QuickBooks | Yes | Often add-on | Businesses wanting personal local relationship |
| Sharma Jyoti and Co | $200/mo | QuickBooks | Yes — always | Included at all tiers | Cost-conscious US small businesses and LLCs |
The Bench Proprietary Software Risk
Data portability matters. Bench uses its own software — not QuickBooks. If you leave Bench, you can download financial statements as PDFs and spreadsheets, but you cannot export a QuickBooks file. This means: (1) your new bookkeeper has to reconstruct your books from scratch or from Bench exports; (2) your US CPA cannot directly import prior-year data. Sharma Jyoti and Co works in QuickBooks Online from day one — your company file is yours to take at any time.
What Bench Charges — Full Price Breakdown
| Plan | Monthly Price | What's Included | What's NOT Included |
|---|---|---|---|
| Essential | $299/mo | Monthly bookkeeping, P&L, balance sheet | Tax filing, CPA workpapers |
| Premium | $499–$899/mo | Bookkeeping + tax filing + year-end | Payroll reconciliation, 1099 e-filing |
Note: Bench pricing scales with revenue. Businesses over $1M/year pay significantly more than the base prices shown above.
Sharma Jyoti and Co vs Bench — 12-Month Cost Comparison
| Business Type | Bench Annual Cost | Sharma Jyoti and Co Annual Cost | Annual Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sole proprietor, low volume | $3,588 (Essential) | $2,400 | $1,188/yr |
| LLC, mid volume | $4,788 (Essential) | $3,600 | $1,188/yr |
| S-corp, with year-end workpapers | $5,988–$10,788 (Premium) | $4,800–$7,200 | $1,188–$3,588/yr |
These savings are before considering that Sharma Jyoti and Co's QuickBooks-based books reduce your US CPA's year-end review time, which typically saves an additional $300–$700 on your CPA's tax preparation bill.