Step 1 — Verify ICAI Registration
The first check is non-negotiable: confirm the CA holds a valid ICAI membership. Go to icai.org → Member Search → enter the membership number or name. The result shows:
- Membership status: Associate Member (ACA) or Fellow Member (FCA). Both are fully qualified CAs — FCA indicates more than 5 years of post-qualification experience.
- Certificate of Practice (COP): A CA in public practice must hold a COP. Without it, they cannot legally sign audit reports or practice on their own account. Ask for the COP number if you need tax audit or statutory audit services.
- Membership number: Any CA who refuses to share this is a red flag. It is a public number and there is no reason to withhold it.
Note: only CAs registered with ICAI can use the designation "Chartered Accountant" and the letters CA before their name in India. "Tax consultant", "accountant", or "financial advisor" are unregulated titles that anyone can use.
Matching the CA Firm to Your Specific Needs
Different CA firms specialise in different types of work. A firm that handles 200 salaried ITR clients per year may not have the experience to handle a complex business with GST scrutiny, export invoicing, and an LLP annual compliance requirement. Match the firm to your specific situation:
| Your Situation | What to Look For in a CA Firm |
|---|---|
| Salaried employee, ITR-1 only | High volume ITR practice, quick turnaround (1–2 weeks), digital document submission, competitive fixed fee |
| Salaried + capital gains from shares/MFs | Experience with ITR-2, familiarity with STCG/LTCG computation, ability to pull broker statement data correctly |
| Small business owner (GST + ITR-3) | Monthly GST filing capability, ITR-3 with P&L and balance sheet, bookkeeping service or coordination with your bookkeeper |
| LLP or private limited company | ROC annual filing (AOC-4, MGT-7), statutory audit capability, DIR-3 KYC compliance |
| Foreign income or NRI | DTAA knowledge, Form 67 for foreign tax credit, FEMA compliance, experience with NRE/NRO account reporting |
Fee Structure — What Is Reasonable?
CA fees vary significantly by city, firm size, and service complexity. The table below gives approximate market rates for common services as of 2025–26:
| Service | Typical Fee Range |
|---|---|
| ITR-1 filing (salaried, no capital gains) | Rs 500 – Rs 2,000 |
| ITR-2 (salaried + capital gains) | Rs 2,000 – Rs 5,000 |
| ITR-3 (business/profession income) | Rs 3,000 – Rs 10,000+ |
| GST returns (monthly GSTR-1 + GSTR-3B) | Rs 1,500 – Rs 5,000/month |
| Tax audit (Section 44AB) | Rs 15,000 – Rs 50,000+ |
| Annual bookkeeping + ITR + GST (small business) | Rs 10,000 – Rs 30,000/year |
Fees significantly below these ranges should be a caution signal — either the firm is cutting corners, using unqualified staff, or will add hidden charges later. Always get the fee in writing and confirm exactly what is included: just filing the return, or also document review, notice response, and follow-up queries.
Red Flags to Avoid
- Promising a guaranteed large refund without reviewing your documents. No CA can know your refund amount without seeing Form 16, AIS, and investment proofs first.
- Refusing to share their ICAI membership number. Every practising CA has one and it is publicly searchable.
- Charging a percentage of your refund as their fee. This is an incentive to inflate deductions — which is tax fraud, not clever planning.
- No written engagement or fee agreement. Verbal-only arrangements leave you unprotected if the work is not done or done incorrectly.
- Cannot explain what deductions they are claiming for you. You sign the ITR — you are responsible for its contents. If the CA cannot explain a deduction in plain language, do not allow it.
- Does not mention the new vs old regime comparison. Any CA filing a salaried ITR should ask about your deductions and compare both regimes before filing. If they file without asking, they may have put you in the wrong regime.
- Staff who are not CAs handling everything with no CA oversight. Legitimate CA firms use staff for data entry, but the CA must review and sign off on every return.
Questions to Ask Before Hiring
- What is your ICAI membership number? (Verify it on icai.org before proceeding.)
- How many clients with my profile (salaried/business/GST) do you handle each year?
- Who will be my day-to-day contact — you or a staff member?
- What is your fixed fee for my specific requirements, and what is included?
- What is excluded from the fee — notices, queries, amendments?
- How do you communicate — email, portal, WhatsApp?
- What is your turnaround time from document submission to filing?
- Do you handle income tax scrutiny notices if I receive one?
- Can you give me two references from existing clients with similar requirements?
A reputable CA firm will answer all of these directly. Evasive answers to questions 1, 3, 4, or 9 are warning signs.
Documents to Hand Over Securely
Once you select a CA, share documents digitally rather than physically wherever possible. Use Google Drive, WhatsApp, or email — avoid sharing original documents. The CA needs:
- Form 16 (Part A and Part B) from your employer
- AIS and Form 26AS downloaded from the income tax portal
- Bank statements for the full financial year
- Investment proofs (LIC, PPF, ELSS, home loan certificate)
- PAN, Aadhaar
- Previous year's ITR acknowledgement (for reference)
Do not share your income tax portal login credentials or net banking access with any CA firm. A CA does not need your portal password — they file on your behalf using their own registered CA login and your Aadhaar OTP for e-verification. Our tax preparation service follows a zero-credential-sharing policy for all clients.
Written by Sharma Jyoti, CA (ICAI) — Founder, Sharma Jyoti and Co. We are an ICAI-registered Chartered Accountant firm. Learn more about our firm →
Related Reading